Jersey Mike’s Buffalo Chicken Recipe – Easy Meal Recipe

Last Updated on March 18, 2025

When it comes to hearty, comforting sandwiches, Jersey Mike’s Buffalo Chicken reigns supreme in my book. Packed with bold flavors and a touch of heat, this delightful option has won my heart and my taste buds.

If you’re curious about what makes this sandwich so special, you’re in for a treat. Let’s dive deep into the world of Jersey Mike’s Buffalo Chicken.

What is Jersey Mike’s Buffalo Chicken?

Picture this: tender, juicy chicken thighs marinated in a zesty buffalo sauce, smothered in gooey provolone cheese, and tucked inside a soft hoagie bun. It’s the perfect balance of spice and creaminess that keeps me coming back for more. 

The beauty of Jersey Mike’s Buffalo Chicken lies not just in its taste but also in its simplicity. You can whip it up at home, too!

Why You’ll Love This Jersey Mike’s Buffalo Chicken

First off, let me tell you—this sandwich is a game changer. It’s a crowd pleaser at parties, a quick weeknight dinner, or a satisfying lunch. 

The tangy buffalo sauce brings excitement, while the creamy blue cheese dressing cools things down. And let’s not overlook the crunchy texture of fresh veggies and the softness of the hoagie bun.

The first bite sends your senses into overdrive; the heat from the buffalo sauce mingles with the richness of the cheese, creating a symphony of flavors. 

You just can’t resist! Whether you’re a spicy food aficionado or just dipping your toe into the world of heat, this sandwich is versatile enough to cater to all palates.

The Ingredients

Here’s a snapshot of what you’ll need to create this mouthwatering sandwich:

• 1 lb boneless, skinless chicken thighs, cut into thin strips
• 2 tablespoons of unsalted butter
• ½ medium sweet onion, thinly sliced
• Salt and freshly cracked black pepper to taste
• ½ cup tangy buffalo wing sauce
• 4 slices of melted provolone cheese
• 2 soft hoagie buns
• Creamy blue cheese dressing
• 1 tablespoon hot honey
• 1 tablespoon finely chopped fresh parsley

Got everything? Great! Let’s move on to the fun part—making the sandwich!

Step by Step Instructions

Step 1: Cook the Chicken

Start by heating the butter in a large skillet over medium heat. Once melted, toss in the sliced onions. Sauté them until they’re nice and translucent, about 3-4 minutes. This step adds a beautiful sweetness to the dish.

Next, season the chicken strips with salt and pepper. Once the onions are ready, add the to the pan. Cook until the chicken is golden brown, about 5-7 minutes.

Step 2: Add the Buffalo Sauce

Once the chicken is cooked through, pour in the buffalo wing sauce. Stir well, ensuring every piece of chicken gets coated. Allow it to simmer for an additional 2-3 minutes. This will help the flavors marry together beautifully.

Step 3: Melt the Provolone

Now, here’s where it gets indulgent. Turn on your broiler. Take the chicken off the heat and lay the provolone slices over the top. 

Broil for about 1-2 minutes, watching closely! Once the cheese gets that deliciously bubbly and slightly browned look, you know it’s ready.

Step 4: Assemble the Sandwich

Slice the hoagie buns in half. Spoon the buffalo chicken mixture onto the bottom half of each bun. 

Drizzle with creamy blue cheese dressing and a touch of hot honey. Top with chopped parsley for that lovely finish. Place the top of the bun back on, and voila!

Tips & Tricks

1. Cheese Choice: Instead of provolone, feel free to try Monterey Jack or cheddar if you prefer a different flavor.
2. Onion Substitute: If you’re not a fan of onions, consider using bell peppers for added crunch.
3. Homemade Buffalo Sauce: If you’re feeling adventurous, mix your own buffalo sauce using melted butter and hot sauce!
4. Spiciness Level: Adjust the heat of the buffalo sauce according to your preference. There are milder versions available.
5. Toasting Buns: For an added crunch, toast the hoagie buns before assembling.

Can I Store Jersey Mike’s Buffalo Chicken?

Absolutely! If you have leftovers (which is rare in my experience), store them in an airtight container in the fridge. It should stay fresh for about 3 days. Just remember that the texture of the chicken may change slightly after reheating, but the flavors will still be on point!

What Can I Serve with Jersey Mike’s Buffalo Chicken?

Pairing is key. Here are some of my favorite sides that complement the flavors perfectly:

• Sweet Potato Fries: The sweetness contrasts beautifully with the spiciness.
• Coleslaw: A chilled, tangy coleslaw can help balance the heat.
• Potato Salad: Another creamy side that’s a favorite at gatherings.
• Fresh Veggie Platter: Crunchy, fresh veggies for a light option.
• Pickles: Tangy, crunchy pickles add a delightful crunch.

Variations

1. Spicy Chicken Tenders: Use the same recipe but swap chicken thighs for tenders. They cook faster and pack a punch.

2. Buffalo Chicken Pasta: Combine the buffalo chicken mixture with cooked pasta for a creamy, baked casserole.

3. Stuffed Peppers: Use the buffalo chicken mix to stuff bell peppers before baking. It’s a unique twist on the classic.

4. Buffalo Chicken Wrap: For a lighter option, wrap the chicken and toppings in a tortilla instead of a hoagie bun.

5. Vegetarian Version: Substitute the chicken with grilled portobello mushrooms tossed in buffalo sauce for a delicious meat-free alternative.

Conclusion

Jersey Mike’s Buffalo Chicken is not just about filling your belly—it’s an experience that brings joy with every bite. From that first bite of tender meat layered with cheese to the satisfying crunch of fresh ingredients, it’s hard not to fall in love. 

Not to mention the versatility of the recipe! Whether you’re hosting a game day party or just craving something different for dinner, this sandwich has got you covered.

I hope you’ve enjoyed this journey into the delicious world of Jersey Mike’s Buffalo Chicken. Give it a try and let it become a staple in your kitchen. Happy cooking!

You’ll also like the following recipes!

• Jersey Mike’s Rosemary Parmesan Bread Copycat Recipe
• How to Make Jersey Mike’s Roast Beef
• Best Jersey Mike’s Chicken Bacon Ranch Recipe